July 14, 2024

One mistake the ‘smart kids’ make with integrated marketing


It’s like the Rubik’s Cube of marketing, only harder to solve.

The smart kids are already at work organizing pieces of the puzzle, trying to find the solution to integrated marketing for the digital age. They are building models that look a lot like integrated marketing from the 90s, but with a focus on digital media.

That might look smart on paper, but it leaves out some integral pieces.

The integration strategies I’ve seen focus on one area of digital marketing at the exclusion of others. The result is only partial integration. Just like a Rubik’s Cube, if one piece is not in place, the puzzle isn’t solved. That’s half-assing it.

Let me explain.

If you do a Google search for “integrated digital marketing” you will find most results lead you to a discussion of how to integrate owned, paid and earned media. Fine. But what about integration across channels? What about integrated communications?

Integrated marketing strategy by definition would have it all tied together. Or would it? Let’s take a look at the definition.

The Wikipedia article on integrated marketing has a number of definitions going back to 1989. This is its most up-to-date definition from STIR Advertising blog:

“True integrated marketing communications is the development of marketing strategies and creative campaigns that weave together multiple marketing disciplines (paid advertising, earned media/PR, promotion, owned assets and social media) that are executed across a variety of media, and selected to suit the particular goals of the brand.”

Notice the emphasis on paid, earned and owned media? I’m not here to try to write another definition to be added to Wikipedia, though. I’ll leave that for the smart kids. But I think it would be useful to look at what can and should be considered in a comprehensive integrated marketing plan.

Integrated media

Since we’ve been talking about paid, earned and owned media, let’s start here. Forrester has done research to help define the terms and uses for digital marketers:

Paid media – Made up of display ads, search ads, sponsored and native ads, paid media has the benefit of immediacy and scaling your message. Paid media feeds owned media, and helps create earned media. While digital advertising in general is losing popularity, paid ads are a catalyst for driving engagement at key times in the sales process.

Earned mediaWord-of-mouth, social media buzz, viral events and public relations are all examples of earned media that gets third party recognition of your brand. This visibility earns you credibility and transparency, which can result in referral sales. The fruits of earned media come from good paid and owned media strategies.

Owned media – Your website, blog and social networks like Twitter are examples of owned media. Control, longevity and versatility are key benefits of owned assets. They enable you to communicate directly with consumers who want to engage with your brand through long-term relationships.


Integrated marketing communications

In the 1990s integrated marketing communications was the gold standard for delivering a unified message across all channels to increase sales and brand awareness at scale. The need for consistent messaging is even greater today.

The reason is obvious.

The proliferation of new digital platforms has given consumers more ways to consume content and engage with your business. And every other business on the digital landscape. Their journey to a buying decision is a winding path filled with bits of information they pick up along the way.

How do you get their attention? Rarely does it happen with one impression. Depending on your sales cycle it could be 5-15 impressions. One model developed by Dr. Jeffrey Lant is to follow the Rule of Seven. This formula assumes it takes seven impressions in an 18-month period to get the attention of a prospective buyer.

Bottom line: making your message consistent throughout the journey is a way to get there faster. It also helps you build credibility and trust with skeptical buyers.

How should you approach integrating your messages? Here are some considerations:

Brand messaging – How you blend your value proposition, positioning and business values into the overall narrative in a way that resonates with your audience.

Content marketing – How you create funnel messages for lead generation and sales that are consistent with your brand story.

Customer care – How your service and support communications create a customer experience that is consistent with your brand.

Context – How your messages fit into different content formats (written, visual, audio, video), and how to adapt your messages to the native culture of each platform. For example, the native language on Twitter is different than Tumblr, Pinterest, Instagram, etc.

Multichannel integration

While there is some overlap with the media discussion above, channel integration takes a different view. Ultimately a multichannel integration strategy will engage prospective customers and guide them through the funnel as you communicate across channels. Its benefits are oriented to building relationships:

  • Connecting through more touch points
  • Creating goodwill by focusing on customer preferences for engagement
  • Creating a seamless experience with your business

A true multichannel strategy should include all channels in which your customer might interact with you – digital and traditional. Depending on your business, it could include:

  • Physical location – store or office
  • Website
  • Email
  • Landline phone
  • Broadcast – radio, TV
  • Direct mail
  • Live events
  • Mobile

That’s a lot to think about. You’re probably wondering if there are any shortcuts. Yes and no. MediaPost has done a study of the most popular multichannel pairings for adults 18-64. It’s no surprise that TV and mobile are the most commonly paired channels. You can see the rest of the results in the graph.


It’s likely for any business that mobile will continue to be important to channel integration. But the bottom line is you need to find out the channel preferences of your target audience and be sure to integrate them within your marketing plan.

The missing piece of the integrated marketing puzzle

If you made it this far you’re probably wondering, what’s the one mistake?

The smart approach digs into the nitty-gritty of integrating media, messages and channels to fully optimize marketing effectiveness. But there’s one piece missing: the customer experience.

We are living in the era of inbound, omnichannel marketing where customers expect a seamless experience regardless of how they are consuming your content or engaging with you. It’s not enough to optimize for digital marketing effectiveness. Customer centricity has to be part of the integrated marketing equation today.

You don’t have to take my word for it. Here is what one of the really smart kids is saying. On the question of what “integrated marketing” means, Lee Odden says:

“I think optimizing customer experience across channels along with optimizing digital marketing effectiveness for brand marketers is a big part of the answer.”

I know there’s more that can be said on this topic. I couldn’t possibly cover it all in one post. So, what else do you think should to be a part of integrated marketing today? I’d be interested in your comments.

Need help with your marketing strategy? Let’s talk! Message me to set up a time to chat on the phone.

Speak Your Mind